Ohh, that's hard. I'd have to say the bag--it's just so CUTE! I love hats--I wear beanies and winter hats whenever I can in fall/winter because they're such fun--but I'm not so big on berets, which is why my personal preference automatically goes to the bag.

But for knitting them, I have no idea which one might be more fun to do. ;)

P.S. Happy birthday again!!!!!! *HUGS*